Quantcast
Question

Schedule or no Schedule?

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

When Adrien was younger (he's 5mo now), I didn't set a schedule for him. I also wasn't staying at home with him full time. Now that I'm at home with him I've put him on a schedle eating every 3 hours. He also tends to nap every 3 hours when he eats. He's been in bed by 8:30 every day I've done this schedule and he's started sleeping through the night (until 6:45am when he wakes up for the day).

Anyway, I used to think babies shouldn't necessarily have schedules until they're old enough to understand. And I still think that to a certian extent. I mean, If Adrien is hungry and it hasn't been 3 hours of course I will still feed him. But I've heard of some moms who ONLY stick to the schedule and will not variate from it at all.

What kind of mom are you? and why do you do what you do?

thanks!

Click to add these tags to your Interests:
SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend Read more:
You must login or register to leave an answer

9 Answers

hi,i have always been less concerned about schedules and more concerned about routine. i have tried not to obsess that my 12 mo old doesn't take a nap at the same time every day (although she's at daycare, so i guess that's easier for me) but do try and have morning and nighttime routines that she can absolutely count on, no matter where we are.  its been easier on me too because if we're out running around on a saturday, i'm not so hard on myself if she's not down for her nap when she "should" be. as long as she get A nap and we have our dinner/bath/bed routine later, it works out.
best of luck to you!

 I completely agree! I'm definitely all for a routine vs. schedule. I guess that's what I meant. I never put him on one, but he's done this himself (which makes it easier on me). I really don't think you should put schedules on kids until they're old enough to understand why and how. Ya know? And I am definitely not one of the moms that won't go do something bc it interferes with his 'schedule'....that just bugs me.

 

Bryany Mommy to Adrien Dean 5.5.06

Bryany
Mommy to Adrien Dean 5.5.06

I believe in letting the child set the schedule, because HELLO! she knows what she needs best (food, nap, play, etc.).

I like to give my daughter little transition cues to let her know what is coming next, for instance, turning off lights and putting on PJ's. Then it triggers her internal clock, telling her "oh, PJ's, it's bedtime soon." And she knows that next we brush teeth, etc. without me having to tell her.

That even works for infants, too. Eventually they know the sound of you making a bottle, or they learn that when you sit in this particular chair it's time to nurse, the lulluby music and paci means naptime, etc.

Feeding a child when he's not hungry (force feeding) is problematic. Same with forcing a child to sleep when his body/mind is not ready to rest.

When your son gets older, into his toddler years, you might begin not doing things because it interferes with his schedule. Toddlers need their naps and snacks, and outings can be very unpleasant for both of you when they're off their little schedules.

Good topic!

MamaHall

MamaHall

We actually believe whole heartedly in schedules!!  My son had jaundice pretty bad when he was born and the hospital enorced a eating every three hour schedule so I could still nurse him while he was under the lights.  Since then we kept his eating times at the same time every day (now he's down to 4 meals). When eating times are always the same, his naps stay at the same time, a short one at 9am and a long one at 2pm.  We did this and he began sleeping through the night at 10 weeks.   Not to say that a 10 minute variance will cause a meltdown, but it just helps us plan our day and he always knows what to expect.  It works for us and we knew what he needed without him having to get worked up trying to communicate.  However, not every kid is the same, and it just happened to work for us because we started from day one. We also use the cues that MamaHall uses which work!

Jessica

 I was so glad that I read a book that said something profound when I was pregnant with my first. It said children are born into the world to parents because they need us to help them learn and to be guided. If a child knew what to do he or she wouldn't need a Mommy and Daddy. Very logical and it rings true with us. Our children seem to find comfort, confidence and stability in knowing the flow of each day for the most part. Of course we vary exact times from day to day should something be going on but especially when they are babies a good eat, wake, sleep schedule has done miracles. It sounds like you experienced the benefit of scheduling when your child started sleeping through the night. Really good topic! All the best!

I don't particularly rely on a schedule because I find that the children are less able to adapt to change when on strict schedules.  When I had my first daughter, I was a fulltime college student.  We stayed up late, slept in, and basically did as we pleased.  She was the happiest, easy-going baby I've had thus far.  As we've aged, my other two daughters do things at approx. the same times everyday and I find they do not adapt as well as my firstborn did to new situations.  When we are less organized with our time, they seem to live in the moment, appreciating the spontaneous things we might do.  My husband favors a schedule, I don't.  Our younger children, being used to an approximate schedule, are less adaptive, but not to the point that we can't go to a birthday party because they HAVE to have that nap @ 12:30!  Skipping a nap won't cause an emotional breakdown at this point, and hopefully, it never will. 

My son has been on a schedule since about 6 months and it is wonderful.  He goes to bed at around 7pm and sleeps until 7am.  The dr. said this is all due to the routine he is on.  Dinner, bath, night time CD at the same time every night. 

 My son will even wave goodbye to us and go to his room when he is ready.  Pretty cool I think.

I prefer the word "routine" too. I learned very early on that if you are consistant with your children they will be consistant with you. I am not afraid to admit my weaknesses and sleep depervation is a BIG weekness of mine. I  knew I had to get my daughter on a regular sleep pattern in order to regain some normal sleep for myself. I breastfed for 15 months but strickly pumped after the third week since my daughter never latched on correctly. Bottle feeding allowed me to get her on a regular feeding routine and regular feedings ment regular sleep.

 Now, I am not a "to the minute" scheduler but the same things happen at about the same time of day give or take a half hour. Since she was 4 months old she fed every 4 hours, 2 hour nap in the AM, 2 hour nap in the PM, Bath, then 10-12 sleep at night. As she grew older and changed her routine, I tweaked it along with what she needed. The 2 naps a day went down to one and the length of the nap has changed too. Her bed time has adjusted a little but still consistant 10-12 hours a night. Now at 3 yrs old, she wakes at 7:30-8:00AM, potty and milk first thing, then about an hour later she wants breakfast, lunch between 12:00-12:30pm, nap right after, wakes at 3pm, dinner at 5-5:30pm, bath and bed by 8-8:30pm. Her bedtime routine always began with a bath everynight until recently. She prefers them in the morning now which is ok because it allows me to get her in bed by 7;30-8pm. Of course lots of activities and errands, housekeeping and playdates inbetween meals and sleep.

I know this doesn't work with all families or children but my older 2 step daughters thrived better in a routine atmosphere and she is following right along too. They know what is expected of them and when and it makes it really easy on me knowing what they need and when. The added bonus is my husband and I get 3 hours minimum to ourselves everynight and I still get my very much needed 6-7 hours sleep a night.

Smile, it increases your face value! Smiley Jodi

Smile, it increases your face value! :)
Jodi

Ever since Kaylee was born I had her on a schedule but it wasn't until she was diagnosed with Hyperinsulinism (opposite of Diabetes) did the schedule become important. Before if she went a hour later on her eating schedule it wasn't an issue. But now we don't have that luxury. She has to eat at certain times. She gets up by 8am and is in bed by 9pm so that she will get up on time. She eats at the same time each day and gets the same amount of food at each feeding. She has to have one more bottle before bed to hold her over through the night.

Oddly enough I think she enjoys this schedule. Perhaps now she recognizes that the medicine schedule and the eating schedule keep her feeling good and she has no problem with it. I don't have to fight her to test her blood or give her, her medicine.

I think she's a far happier baby with the schedule.

You must login or register to leave an answer